The No-Fly Zone Conundrum

: Leaving Kyiv, March, 2022, photo courtesy of independent.co.uk

Logical fallacies do not prepare deliberation or offer resolution. Like a smoke screen they defy investigation, keeping the observer blinded.

“No Fly Zone,” (NFZ) is a recent case. If the consequence of putting in place a NFZ is a challenge to future humanity, the reckoning is placed disproportionately. Survivors of such a reckoning will be challenged by scarcity. That’s not reassuring for civilization inspired by abundance.

Consider rather why some sanctions are effective, some not. (1) Sanctions are totems of solidarity. Like a boycott, sanctions go beyond sending “a message.” Sanctions channel sacrifice. Sanctions fill a void offered by abundance.

Consider that a NFZ is a void. It is a carryover from nation-statism in an increasingly interconnected world.

Reality speaking, the earth is a no-fly zone, and specific no-fly zones are carved-out ‘shoot-to-kill-zones.’ (2)

A NFZ is an exercise in militarism. Enter a NFZ and one is threatened with annihilation. A NFZ like a gauntlet once thrown sets up an ultimate tragedy. There is no turning back: the duel must play out until one is wounded or killed.

A NFZ is not an imprint of a cease-fire border. There are no check-points. There is no accommodation. So that nation-states can control access from a distance, a NFZ proposes a moving target

The argument for a NFZ is that it contains wider military escalation. This is nonsense, tactically speaking. Less tangible, cheaper, resources exist: biological warfare, cluster bombs, leaked radiation. Go to the zero-sum duel metaphor: a NFZ is like the command, “gentlemen, choose your weapon.”

So child refugees understand.

March 16

1-Why Sanctions Too Often Fail https://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/why-sanctions-too-often-fail

2-https://link.medium.com/BvjFblYtrob

--

--

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Rodney Clough

Rodney Clough

Refuses to nap. Septuagenarian. Cliche’ raker. Writes weekly.