Election 2020: Voting for a Government.2

My late night/morning conversation with Parisian friend, Michel continues (to pick up the earlier conversation see Medium post, “Election 2020: Voting for Government,” October 1)

Me: Let’s get back to your idea that maybe for the first time with this election American voters are voting for “a government.”

Michel: Yes. The American press is warning the world that America is on the brink of losing its “soul,” ceasing to be a democracy, is experiencing a constitutional crisis.

Let’s look at this another way. What is the opposite political idea to democracy, “anti-democracy?”

Me: Authoritarianism?

Michel: Exactly. Authoritarianism, fascism. Fascists need a conspiracy. Think about the 1933 Reichstadt Fire. Something has to be going on all the time to trap and capture the public imagination. Some distraction, some “shiny object.”

Me: Go on.

Michel: Never a mirror. Mirrors reflect the viewer, or the “poseur.”.

Me: What?

Michel: Reflection is anathema to fascists. I was amused by a reporter on one of your cable TV newscasts who was accosted by a non-mask wearer at a Trump Rally. Shouting at the reporter who was masked, the. Trump supporter screamed, “look at you, you’re disgusting!” This is a blatant attempt to subvert the reflection process by shaming the reporter for taking a public precaution..PUBLIC. For fascist enablers and followers there is no space for notions of PUBLIC or polity. This Trump follower exhibited disdain for reflection.

Me: But what does this have to do with voting for a government?

Michel: Follow me here. To move on past the cult of personality to reflect on where a people, a public is at, what the challenges are… this is what I mean when I say the task at hand for American voter(s) is to vote for a government. It requires discipline, maturity.

Me: I’m listening.

Michel: In France we understand Bernie Sanders who was the first candidate to say, “It’s not about me, it’s about you (us).” This statement for most Americans I think represents a departure from American individualism. Actually it doesn’t but that’s another conversation.

Me: I think I am beginning to understand. So you’re saying that it takes imagination to move past the “cult of personality.”

Michel: Oui! And a government which abets the process of, enables active reflection, is a government which places a value on civility. To build a democracy you need space for imagination. Something I would add France is not terribly good at.

Me: Excuse me but you seem to know A LOT about America. Are the French all that much better at reflection?

Michel: Speaking for my friends who tolerate America’s excesses, even now, we need America. Remember Lafayette? His shining moment was helping build America. We have. — as you Americans like to say — France has “skin in the game.”

Me: And the names on the ballot, what do they tell us?

Michel: Now you’re onto it. But Gregoire is pestering me. Talk later?

Me: Yes.

October 2, 2020



Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Rodney Clough

Rodney Clough

Refuses to nap. Septuagenarian. Cliche’ raker. Writes weekly.